Over $5.85 Million Paid for 44 African-American Men Strip Searched on the Street under Oakland's Unconstitutional Policy
For more than a decade, the Oakland Police Department had a practice, and eventually a written policy, allowing officers to strip search people right on the street in broad daylight. Haddad & Sherwin teamed up with John Burris to represent dozens of men - all African-American - who were subjected to this offensive and illegal police misconduct. Some of these cases lasted almost ten years, in the course of which, we obtained an important court ruling striking down Oakland's unconstitutional strip search policies, we won a trial with punitive damages for two men, and achieved a sweeping $4.6 million settlement for the remaining 39 men. Altogether, these related cases resulted in verdicts and settlements over $5,850,000, and a sweeping agreement that includes a new lawful OPD strip search policy and re-training, with court oversight and enforcement.
Oakland to pay $4.6 million in strip search cases
Matthew Artz, Oakland Tribune, November 14, 2012
OAKLAND -- Council members voted Tuesday to pay $4.6 million in damages to 39 plaintiffs who accused Oakland police of illegally strip-searching them in public between 2002 and 2009. "It's been a very long time for many of our guys for this acknowledgment," the plaintiffs'attorney Michael Haddad said. "This settlement is vindication of their rights and their claims." ... Oakland has since revised its strip-search policy, but Haddad said it still gives officers broad powers to conduct searches in public, especially for parolees. "If we can't agree on a policy," he said, "we're going to have to take them back to court."
Public strip search costs ex-Oakland Cop $40K
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, November 8, 2011
A former Oakland police officer must pay $40,000 out of his own pocket to two men who were illegally strip-searched in public and have already been awarded at least $100,000 apiece in damages. Spencer Troy Lucas and Kirby Bradshaw had their pants pulled down on a busy West Oakland street in 2005 by police after then-Officer Ingo Mayer stopped them for no lawful reason, U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel wrote in an August ruling after a bench trial. In the ruling, the judge ordered the city to pay $105,000 in compensatory damages to Lucas and $100,000 to Bradshaw. On Friday, the judge ordered Mayer to pay $25,000 to Lucas and $15,000 to Bradshaw. "She thought it was important to send a message to penalize this officer for his flagrant violation of constitutional rights," the men's attorney, Michael Haddad, said Monday. Mayer retired on disability as a result of the trial, the judge said.
Men stripped by Oakland cops in public win lawsuit; Judge to Assess Punitive Damages Soon
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, August 5, 2011
OAKLAND -- Two men were illegally stripsearched by Oakland police in public and will each receive at least $100,000 in damages, a federal judge ruled Thursday. ... Both men testified "to their humiliation and feelings of degradation as a result of this public spectacle, as well as the subsequent recurrent memories of feeling terrorized," Patel wrote. "The testimony of the feeling of 'submissiveness' also speaks to the sense of degradation," the judge said. "This feeling is particularly poignant when viewed in light of the history of young black men in this country." ... The fate of 39 other men who have also sued the city is on hold because Patel is retiring, said attorneys John Burris and Michael Haddad, who represent all the plaintiffs.
Judge orders damages in Oakland police strip search
Angela Woodall, Oakland Tribune, August 5, 2011
A federal judge on Thursday ruled that Oakland police unlawfully strip-searched two men and ordered that the city pay them more than $200,000. ... In 2008, Patel struck down two policies related to strip-searches as unconstitutional. On Thursday, she dismissed the cases of three other men. "That means there's 39 remaining," Attorney Michael Haddad said. "This is only the tip of the iceberg."
Strip-Search Suits Get Day in Court
Dan Levine, The Recorder, March 10, 2010
After all the pretrial publicity and years of motion practice, the value of 44 strip-search suits against the Oakland Police Department may come down to the credibility of a part-time city pool cleaner.
Oakland Strip-Search Law Ruled Unconstitutional
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, March 29, 2008
The Oakland Police Department's strip-search policy is unconstitutional because it provides too low a threshold for officers seeking to check for contraband on suspects in public places, a federal judge said in a ruling made public Friday.
Federal Lawsuit Against Oakland Over Public Strip Searches
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, August 21, 2007
Six men have filed a $5 million federal civil rights lawsuit against the city of Oakland, saying police officers conducted invasive and illegal strip searches of them in public. "Every police officer knows that to go into your home, they have to have a warrant," Haddad said Monday. "What we're talking about is an officer going into your pants."
Oakland Faces Lawsuit Over Police Strip-Searches
Heather MacDonald, Oakland Tribune, March 30, 2007
OAKLAND - Seven residents sued the city of Oakland Wednesday, claiming police officers improperly strip searched them on city streets, humiliated them and violated their civil rights. The federal suit, which asks for $5 million and an end to the practice, brings the number to 15 who said they were illegally stopped and forced to remove their clothes by Oakland officers.
Suit Alleges Police Did Strip Searches in Public
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, March 30, 2007
In the latest of several suits over strip searches, seven men have filed a $5 million federal civil rights lawsuit against the city of Oakland, saying officers conducted invasive and illegal strip searches of them in public.
Unwarranted Search by Police Alleged
Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, August 9, 2005
An Antioch man filed a federal civil rights lawsuit Monday against the city of Oakland, saying two officers conducted an invasive search of him for no reason.